About Peter Middleton Insurance, LLC
About Us
A Legacy of Trust and Protection Since 1986
At Peter Middleton Insurance, we believe insurance is more than just a policy it's a promise to protect what matters most. Since 1986, Peter Middleton has served individuals, families, and retirees across Pompano Beach, FL, and surrounding areas with one goal: to provide honest, reliable, and personalized insurance solutions.
With nearly four decades of experience, Peter has built a reputation as a knowledgeable and approachable insurance broker who puts his clients first. Whether you’re navigating complex Medicare enrollment, comparing life insurance options, or preparing for retirement with annuities, you can count on expert guidance every step of the way.
Our Founder
Meet Peter Middleton
Peter Middleton is a licensed, independent insurance broker with deep roots in the South Florida community. He founded his agency to offer a better alternative to one-size-fits-all insurance companies focusing instead on tailored advice, education, and ongoing support.
Over the years, Peter has helped thousands of clients find affordable and effective coverage that protects their health, income, and legacy. His specialty lies in health insurance particularly helping clients understand and enroll in Medicare and Medicaid, along with life insurance and annuity products for long-term financial security.
What sets Peter apart is his commitment to clear communication and 24/7 availability. Clients know they can reach him directly, ask questions without pressure, and make confident decisions based on real guidance not sales tactics.
Why We Do What We Do
Insurance is a deeply personal decision and it should be treated that way. At Peter Middleton Insurance, we take the time to understand your situation, walk you through your options, and recommend plans that actually fit your needs and your budget.
We serve:
Whether you're shopping for your first plan or reviewing your current coverage, our team is here to simplify the process and support you for the long haul.
Our Core Values
Integrity
We believe in honest conversations, transparent options, and recommendations based on what's best for you not what's best for a carrier.
Expertise
With nearly 40 years in the industry, we understand how policies work, what’s changing in health and government programs, and how to help you stay protected.
Accessibility
We're available 24/7 by phone or email. Whether it's a quick question or a full plan review, you're never alone in the decision-making process.
Personal Service
No call centers, no bots. Just real conversations with real people who care about your peace of mind.
Our Specialties
We don’t believe in cookie-cutter insurance. Every plan we recommend is carefully selected to suit your age, health, financial situation, and future goals.
Life Insurance
Term, Whole, and Final Expense Coverage
Living Benefits and Cash Value Policies
Health Insurance
Individual and Family Plans
Medicare Advantage & Supplement Plans
Medicaid Guidance
Annuities
Retirement Income Planning
Fixed and Indexed Annuities
Let’s Start a Conversation
If you’re unsure where to begin with your insurance planning, you’re not alone. Most people feel overwhelmed by the number of options and the lack of clear advice. That’s exactly why Peter Middleton started this agency to make insurance feel simple, approachable, and empowering.
There’s no pressure, no jargon, and no obligation just a conversation about how to protect your future.
Call Peter today at (954) 263-1410 or email protect@pjmins.com.
We’re here to help 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.